Start Here: Exploring & Stage 1
Your step-by-step survival guide to the Church of England Shared Discernment Process (SDP)
How does Church of England discernment work?
The Shared Discernment Process (SDP) begins locally with your Vicar and Diocesan Director of Ordinands (DDO), where you complete Safer Recruitment paperwork and reflect on the Six Qualities before entering Stage 1 (The Carousels). This hub is your Translation Matrix: decoding the institutional jargon so you can navigate early discernment safely and authentically.
The Early Discernment Translation Matrix
Official Church of England literature gives you the formal terminology; this matrix starts to give you the practical reality of what each step involves, what assessors are actually looking for, and how to navigate it without burning out.
| Stage & Official CofE Term | What It Actually Means (In Plain English) | What They Are Looking For | The Called & Tested Strategy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Exploring a Vocation (Local Parish Discernment) | The Spark & The First Conversation: Taking the feeling out of your head and speaking to your local Vicar or incumbent. This is not a formal interview; it is a series of pastoral conversations over several months to explore whether you feel drawn to ordained priesthood, the distinctive diaconate, or Licensed Lay Ministry (Reader). | Honesty over perfection. Your Vicar does not expect polished theological answers or for you to have read the entire Bible. They want to hear the authentic story of your calling and see how you respond to local church life. | Use the "Wait and See" Protocol: Resist the urge to rush or script "pious" answers. Share the feeling early with your spouse or a trusted confidant, take notes in meetings, and ask your Vicar to set clear deadlines for any reading tasks. |
| 2. Diocesan Referral (Meeting the DDO / ADDO) | Your Regional Navigator: Your Diocesan Director of Ordinands (DDO) or Assistant DDO (ADDO) is the institutional expert who guides you through the Shared Discernment Process (SDP) and eventually sponsors you for national panels. Meetings cover both your spiritual calling and practical life logistics (family, work, and potential training pathways). | Self-awareness and teachability. Your DDO is your biggest cheerleader, not a hostile examiner. They need to know your real strengths and friction points—including any fear of "The Academic Wall"—so they can support you properly. | Give Them Your Brain's Instruction Manual: Unmask early. If you are neurodivergent or struggle with admin, ask for what you need upfront: digital forms for text-to-speech (Dyslexia), hard deadlines (ADHD), or written meeting agendas in advance (Autism). |
| 3. Safer Recruitment (Pre-Stage 1 Administration) | The Paperwork Mountain: The mandatory administrative gateway required before you can attend a national panel. This includes national registration forms, a full career and ministry CV, Enhanced DBS (Disclosure and Barring Service) checks, references, and online Church of England Safeguarding modules. | Safety, transparency, and safeguarding compliance. The Church has a legal and pastoral duty to ensure every candidate in public ministry is safe to work with children and vulnerable adults. | Break the Bureaucratic Wall: Admin heavy-lifting often triggers executive dysfunction and paralysis. Never tackle the paperwork alone in one sitting—chunk it into 20-minute sprints, use body-doubling, and ask your DDO or spouse to hold you accountable to specific completion dates. |
| 4. The Six Qualities (SDP Assessment Framework) | The Rosetta Stone: The six national criteria against which all Church of England candidates are discerned (Love for God, Call to Ministry, Love for People, Wisdom, Fruitfulness, and Potential). You will write short reflective pieces demonstrating how these qualities are emerging in your life and church context. | Grounded, real-world evidence rather than abstract essays. Assessors want to see how you handle mistakes, how you love real people in your parish, and whether your faith has roots that can weather the demands of ministry. | Translate, Don't Mask: Stop trying to sound like a Victorian textbook. Use everyday examples from your secular job, family life, and parish volunteering. Frame neurodivergent traits (like pattern-matching, hyper-empathy, and creative problem-solving) as genuine pastoral strengths. |
| 5. Stage 1 Panel (National Carousel Interviews) | Stage 1 — The Carousels: The first formal national assessment stage of the SDP. Conducted online via video call, you rotate through a carousel of 25-minute sprint interviews with different national Bishops' Advisers, each focusing on specific Qualities. | Clarity, reflection, and concise communication under time limits. Advisers are checking that your written reflections match how you speak about your calling in person, and that you are ready to progress to the Stage 2 Residential. | Master the 25-Minute Sprint: 25 minutes flies by—rambling or over-explaining is the biggest trap. Keep visual bullet-point prompts near your webcam, pause before answering, and request reasonable adjustments (such as questions pasted into the Zoom chat) before panel day. |
| 6. Parallel Tracks (APW & Faculty Panels) | Special Assessments & C4 Faculty: Additional supportive or legal steps that run alongside the main SDP for many candidates. This includes the Assessment for Pastoral Wellbeing (APW) with a psychologist or a Canon C4 Faculty if you or your spouse have a previous marriage and divorce. | Resilience, emotional health, and pastoral stability. These are not traps designed to fail you; they exist to verify that you have the support systems, emotional boundaries, and self-care habits to survive public ministry. | Shift from "Patient" to "Candidate": Dismantle the panic. Treat the APW as a collaborative conversation about how you stay healthy, protect a Vocation-Free Zone at home with your spouse, and communicate openly about your wellbeing. |
Stage 1 Guides
Book Review – Faithful? Foolish? Called: Recognising God’s call and what to do about it
If you’ve ever felt that way, Mark Tanner’s Faithful? Foolish? Called: Recognising God’s call and what to do about it is going to feel like a massive breath of fresh air.
The Timeline for Ministry Discernment
Feeling a call to ministry is a big deal. It can be life-changing, exciting, and, frankly, a little overwhelming at times. The prospect of navigating the Church of England’s discernment process might feel particularly daunting, regardless of your background or life...
When Daily Prayer Routines Don’t Work
For many of us navigating discernment with ADHD or Dyslexia (or any other Neurodiversity), the traditional image of the "Quiet Time"—sitting silently, eyes closed, absorbing Scripture for 30 consecutive minutes—is a source of deep spiritual failure. It’s not that we...
Disclosing ADHD/Dyslexia to the Church
The discernment process requires us to stand before two very different groups: the Diocese (for the formal structure of assessment) and our PCC/Congregation (to enable personal growth throughout discernment). For a neurodivergent candidate, disclosing conditions like...
Is Your Vocation Real or a Hyperfixation?
For many of us with ADHD, intense passion for ministry often begins with a powerful surge of energy that looks exactly like a hyperfixation. The excitement is real, and the desire to study, serve, and write is overwhelming. But discernment is a process designed to...
A Confession: I’ve Been Called, But I Can’t Process the Bible
What we are talking about: The hardest part of my vocational call wasn't the Church, it was the sheer volume of reading. The fear of not being accepted or supported within the CofE due to my neurodiversity was unfounded. You do not need to read every physical word to...
Read the Ordinand Journal
Get Andy's personal reflections, Lent journals, and systemic critiques on discernment,
ordination and neurodivergent ministry straight to your inbox.
Frequently Asked Questions: Early Discernment & Stage 1
Do I need to be a theological scholar or have a degree to begin discernment?
Absolutely not. The Church of England expects life experience, a genuine faith, and a willingness to learn—not a pre-packaged academic. Whether you are returning to study after decades or managing specific learning profiles like dyslexia, Theological Education Institutions (TEIs) offer flexible pathways ranging from residential degrees to part-time, context-based training. Your DDO will help match your learning style to the right environment.
What happens if the paperwork and administrative requirements feel overwhelming?
The administrative mountain—including registration forms, CVs, DBS checks, and safeguarding modules—can trigger intense executive dysfunction and anxiety for many candidates. You do not have to tackle it alone. Break tasks into small 20-minute sprints, ask a trusted partner for body-doubling, and let your DDO or vocations team know if you need practical reasonable adjustments (such as digital formats or clear deadlines) to help you through the process.
How long does the local discernment stage take before reaching Stage 1?
There is no fixed timeline. For some, initial conversations with a local minister and DDO take under six months. For others—especially those balancing demanding secular careers, family life, or health considerations—it can take a year or two of steady, prayerful preparation. Take your time; the process is designed to test a vocation, not rush you into burnout.
What is actually tested during a Stage 1 Panel (The Carousels)?
Stage 1 consists of a series of short online interviews (structured as 25-minute sprint carousels) with national Bishops' Advisers. They evaluate your calling against the Church's Six Qualities for Discernment. They want to hear authentic stories, grounded parish experience, and how you articulate your faith, rather than rehearsed or overly formal theological answers.
Should I disclose health conditions, mental health history, or neurodivergence to my DDO?
Disclosure is always your choice, but we champions"unmasking safely." Being open about your real-world needs and how you manage them allows your DDO to put proper support structures in place early. Rather than hiding your friction points, discussing them demonstrates deep self-awareness, maturity, and resilience—qualities that national assessors actively look for.
